How many more should we allow to die?

It is the beginning of ember months. Many people see the ember months as the most dreadful months of the year, because activities of the year begin to ramp up very fast. So also, people become vulnerable to various vices, and road crash is not exempted. And looking back in the year, the rate of crashes is been unsettling!

Is it the ghastly crash that left eleven people dead at Otedola Bridge or the still fresh August crash on third mainland bridge that left five dead (including children) on the spot and fifteen injured, both in Lagos?

Knowing fully that there are lot more crashes that never made the news.
All that said, nothing much might change in the future considering the way we conduct and conclude on our safety investigations and the outcomes we derive from them – outcomes that do not address systems and processes, but indict individual’s action/inactions.

Let us consider one of the high profile incident below as an example.

March 6, 2016 Nigeria lost a Minister, a Senior Advocate, a father, an energetic and patriotic citizen. That was not all; his wife and son died in the same incident. Why should a family bear such magnitude of loss in a day?

There was a momentary silence, the news was punctuated with condolences, the rest now is history; many have died thereafter and dying still in very similar preventable circumstances.
“What killed The Honourable Minister of State for Labour,” you may ask. “Is it driver error, safety negligence or less than adequate system?”
Permit me to advocate this unsettling trend of how we go about crash investigation and what happened thereafter.

Excerpt of the report published by the Road Safety Lead Agency – Federal Road Safety Corps (FRSC) revealed some facts that may have led to the crash of Late Minister.

Firstly, on tyres, it was confirmed that tyres on the vehicle were not expired; this must have been verified by inspection after crash, but report had it that someone in the back up convoy vehicle noticed that the tyre that later burst looked under inflated (could this have caused a blow out? very likely!) unfortunately, there was no record to substantiate this claim.

Though tyre burst is serious enough to cause a crash, the question we should answer is do all tyre burst lead to the kind of outcome we got from this crash?
Still on tyre, most likely, after crash inspection revealed wrong tyre installation, to what degree could this have contributed to the crash? Maybe not!

What is the consequence of wrong tyre installation? Wrong installation of directional tyres can only expose vehicle to poor traction in wet weather. There was no mentioning of bad the weather or slippery road condition before the crash? Oh! It looks like there are more questions to ask.

Speed, very common claim of most crashes not only in Nigeria. The driver was driving too fast, how fast, at what speed? How do we arrive at this conclusion? Is it a standard of assumption or scientific? Reports do not provide basis of inference.

It is known that speed increases risk of a crash, is it possible to have this type of crash even at speed below the legal limit? How strong was the wind at this time? What factors conspired to make the crash happen? Was there any investigation before coming up with the facts in the public domain or personnel who go for rescue make personal judgement of what they feel led to a crash and develop report around it?

Driver, some of the outcomes of the investigation in this incident are more logical, comical than scientific.The height of them has to do with the driver not in possession of a valid licence (name not found in the national driver licence database).

It is less considerable to think that a valid licence would do any magic in that circumstance other than a driver who knows what to do, or do you think not possessing a valid licence caused the crash? While it may be difficult to validate driver’s claim to wanting to renew licence upon expiration, it will be noteworthy if our licence process can be less cumbersome and efficient; such that gives legitimate citizen opportunity to do the right thing.
Seat belt, among the causes mentioned was non-usage of seat. Seat belts do not prevent crashes. It will only reduce…

Want to read full article? Subscribe to get Safety Record Newspaper

Post Author: Paul Mbagwu